What Is The Problem With the Manual Accounts Payable Process?
Before diving into implementation essentials, it’s crucial to understand why other finance leaders are making the switch. Manual accounts payable processing creates significant operational challenges that impact both efficiency and accuracy. The most critical issues include:
- Time consumption: Invoice data entry consumes 30 hours per month on average, with finance teams spending up to 60% of their time on manual processing tasks.
- High error rates: Manual processes typically produce 3-5% error rates, leading to duplicate payments.
- Poor visibility: Without centralised tracking, teams cannot monitor invoice status, approval bottlenecks, or payment timelines effectively.
- Scaling limitations: As businesses grow, manual AP processes cannot handle increased invoice volumes without proportional staff increases.
- Compliance risks: Paper-based records make audit preparation time-intensive and increase the risk of documentation gaps during compliance reviews. These challenges compound as organisations grow, making AP automation essential for businesses processing more than 100 invoices monthly.
What Is The Impact of AP Automation on Finance Roles?
AP automation will transform your finance team's roles rather than eliminate them. The impact varies by role level, with each position experiencing distinct changes in responsibilities:
- AP Clerks: Instead of spending 60-70% of your time manually keying invoice data, you'll transition to managing exceptions, resolving discrepancies, and handling supplier queries. Your role becomes more analytical.
- AP Managers: As an AP manager, you'll shift from daily firefighting and approval chasing to strategic process improvement and data-driven decision-making. Your focus will expand to analysing supplier performance and negotiating early payment discounts.
- Finance Controllers: You'll benefit from enhanced visibility and control over your entire AP process without constant manual oversight. You'll also gain stronger audit trails and compliance documentation.
- CFOs and Finance Directors: AP automation delivers the strategic benefits you need. You'll be able to identify spending trends, cost-saving opportunities, and budget variances across departments.
How Do You Compare AP Automation Platforms?
Now that you know how your role will evolve with AP automation, next, you need to evaluate which AP automation software fits your specific business requirements, existing systems, and finance team structure. Use this comparison framework to assess AP automation providers objectively:
- Integration compatibility: Start by confirming the platform integrates natively with your accounting system.
- Feature alignment with your pain points. Map your biggest AP challenges to required features. For example, if fraud is your concern, prioritise the bank details checker.
- Pricing structure transparency: AP automation pricing varies significantly. Compare the providers' pricing structure, whether per-invoice pricing, subscription-based and hidden costs like extra users, and premium features.
- Implementation requirements: Understand what you'll need to invest beyond software costs, like internal resources and training required.
- User experience and adoption. Even the most feature-rich platform fails if your team can’t easily use it. It is essential to evaluate whether the AP automation platform is intuitive or requires extensive training.
- Scalability and flexibility. Your business will grow and change. Evaluate if the platform can handle growing invoice volume or more complex requirements as you scale.
- Security and compliance credentials: Verify the platform meets security standards like ISO compliance, GDPR compliance and data encryption.
- Customer support quality: Support quality varies dramatically between vendors. Research what support hours are available, and the average response time for issues. Read customer reviews specifically about support experiences when you decide to buy an AP automation software.
We’ve created an AP Provider Comparison Framework to help you make the right choice.
What Features To Look For In Accounts Payable Automation Tools?
If you’re unsure which features best align with your AP needs, there are a few key capabilities your chosen AP automation solution should deliver effectively. These include:
- AI-based data extraction: Look for software that uses artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (not just basic OCR) to extract data from your invoices. AI-based extraction can read any invoice format, whether it's a structured PDF, a photo taken on a phone, or a poorly scanned document with skewed text. With AI, your extraction accuracy actually increases over time, and you spend less time correcting data.
- Bank details checker: This feature protects you from one of the most common and costly forms of AP fraud: payment redirection. It checks the extracted bank details on an invoice against your own records and automatically flags if there’s a mismatch.
- Auto-routed approvals Your AP automation software should intelligently route invoices to the right approvers based on rules you configure. Set up conditional logic based on invoice amount, supplier details, cost centre, or department, and the system automatically sends invoices to the appropriate approvers in the right sequence.
- Automated 3-way matching: 3-way matching is your financial control mechanism that prevents paying for goods or services you didn't receive or didn't order. The system automatically matches three documents: the purchase order (what you ordered), the goods receipt or delivery note (what you actually received), and the supplier invoice (what you're being asked to pay). This eliminates manual reconciliation work and catches errors before payment goes out.
- Mobile app: Your AP automation needs to work wherever your team is, not just at their desks. A mobile app enables your approvers to review and approve invoices from their phones during commutes, between meetings, or while travelling, keeping your AP process moving even when key decision-makers aren't in the office.
Why these five features matter most: Together, these features address the most significant AP pain points. When evaluating AP automation vendors, test these specific capabilities during demos.
How Does AP Automation Reduce Risk of Fraud?
AP automation dramatically reduces your fraud risk by eliminating the vulnerabilities inherent in manual processes and implementing multiple layers of automated controls that catch fraudulent activity before payments are made.
Payment redirection and bank detail fraud: This is one of the fastest-growing fraud types. Criminals intercept emails, impersonate suppliers, or compromise vendor accounts to request bank detail changes. Your AP team, believing they're updating legitimate information, redirects payments to fraudster-controlled accounts. By the time you realise the fraud, the money is gone and often unrecoverable.
How automation prevents it: Immediately flag any modification to vendor payment information. Additionally, there is a complete audit trail record of who requested the change, who approved it, when it occurred, and what the previous details were, creating accountability that deters internal fraud.
Fraud prevention is just one aspect of security. Learn about 5 more ways AP automation strengthens cybersecurity.
How to get team buy-in for AP automation?
To get your team to embrace AP automation, address their concerns directly and clearly communicate how automation enhances their work. Here's your approach:
- Address job security fears immediately: Your AP staff's biggest concern is whether automation will eliminate their positions. Be transparent from the start. Frame automation as removing the tedious parts of their work while making their expertise more valuable.
- Involve your team in automation selection: Bring your team into software demos and evaluation sessions. Let them test the platform and ask questions. When your team is involved in the decision-making process, they develop ownership of the outcome.
- Highlight personal benefits, not just business benefits: Your team needs to understand what's in it for them individually, whether it’s fewer late nights, reduced stress or potential career advancement as they take on strategic responsibilities.
- Acknowledge the transition difficulty: Be honest that the first few weeks will be challenging as your team learns new workflows while maintaining their usual responsibilities. When you acknowledge the difficulty and provide support, your team feels respected rather than just pushed to adopt new technology.
How To Automate Accounts Payable?
When you're ready to automate accounts payable, the process breaks down into 4 practical steps:
- Choose the right AP automation software
Select a platform that integrates with your existing accounting system and offers the above-discussed features. Finally, look for cloud-based solutions that require minimal IT infrastructure and can scale with your business. - Integrate with your accounting system
Connect your AP automation platform to your accounting or ERP system to ensure seamless data flow. This integration enables automatic coding of invoices to the correct GL accounts, real-time synchronisation of supplier details, and direct posting of approved invoices without duplicate entry. - Set up user permissions
Define role-based access controls to determine what each user can view and action within the system. Assign permissions based on job role: from admin to approvers who review invoices & POs. - Set up your approval workflows
Configure multi-level approval workflows that automatically route invoices to the right people based on invoice amounts, cost centres, or departments. Modern AP systems allow you to create conditional logic. For example, invoices under £500 auto-approve with one manager, while those above £5,000 require the CFO’s sign-off.
For detailed AP implementation steps, check out our AP implementation guide.
What resources are needed for AP automation implementation?
- Internal team time: Your finance team needs dedicated time for documenting workflows, cleansing vendor data, configuring the system, testing processes, attending training, and managing the transition.
- Data preparation work: Before implementation, document current approval workflows and thresholds, and review your chart of accounts to ensure GL codes are current and properly defined.
- Workflow documentation: Map your current approval workflows, thresholds, delegation rules, and exception handling procedures as the blueprint for system configuration.
- Change management and training: Budget time for team communication, comprehensive training sessions, ongoing support as staff adapt to new workflows, and active monitoring during the initial rollout period to resolve issues quickly.
How long does AP automation implementation take?
There's no definitive timeline for AP automation implementation as it depends on your invoice complexity, approval workflow intricacy, and internal resource availability. However, if you choose a quality automation provider, you should expect to be up and running within just a few weeks rather than months.
Modern cloud-based platforms with native accounting integrations, pre-built templates, and comprehensive onboarding support typically achieve go-live in 4-6 weeks for straightforward implementations. More complex scenarios, such as multi-entity businesses, custom approval hierarchies, or extensive data migration requirements, may take slightly longer.
The key differentiator is your provider's implementation approach: quality providers offer dedicated onboarding support, clear project timelines, and realistic milestone expectations that keep your project on track.
How to manage this transition successfully?
Managing your transition to AP automation successfully requires clear communication, team involvement, and realistic expectations from day one. Start by addressing your team's job security concerns directly and reassure them that automation transforms their roles rather than eliminates them.
Invest in comprehensive training with multiple sessions, hands-on practice environments, and ongoing support during the critical first 4-8 weeks. Begin with quick wins by automating your simplest, highest-volume invoice types first, allowing your team to build confidence before tackling complex exceptions.
Designate "automation champions" within your team (enthusiastic early adopters) who can provide peer-to-peer support to their colleagues. Most importantly, acknowledge that the transition period will be challenging and provide the necessary support.
When you combine transparent communication, adequate training, phased rollout, and genuine support, your team will transition from resistance to advocacy.
Final Thoughts
Is Your AP Function Ready for Automation?
Every month you delay implementing AP automation, it represents continued exposure to fraud, missed early payment discounts, late fees, and countless hours your team spends on manual work that could be automated. Meanwhile, your competitors are gaining efficiency advantages that compound over time.
The question isn't whether to automate, it's when and with whom.